fallout

It's a simple business dispute, got it? Trudy's sitting on a pile of goods that she owes me.Wolfgang

Order Up is a side quest in Fallout 4.

Quick walkthrough

Side quest: Order Up 
Talk to Wolfgang 
Kill Trudy 
Intimidate Wolfgang to leave. 
Talk to Wolfgang 
Talk to Trudy 
Talk to Trudy 
Reward: 150 XP
100/125/150/200 caps 
Reward: 150 XP
140 caps 
Convince Trudy to pay Wolfgang 
Kill Wolfgang 
Talk to Wolfgang 
Talk to Trudy 
Reward: 150 XP
100/125/150/200 caps 
Reward: 150 XP
100/125/150/200 caps 

Detailed walkthrough

Traveling southeast of Concord, one can discover a Drumlin Diner location and when first approaching, they will hear an argument between the owner, Trudy and a chem dealer, Wolfgang who's backed up by his bodyguard Simone. The player character can:

  1. Enter the diner and talk to Trudy. All conversation options result in her offering money for the player character to kill Wolfgang. The player character can ask for extra, accept or refuse.
  2. Talk to Wolfgang. He and Simone will initially draw their weapons, but it is still possible to ask what is going on.

If Wolfgang is not hostile or has not been driven off, he will ask for help, with either talking some sense into Trudy or taking her down.

The default payout is 100 caps, but the player character can haggle for 125, 150 or as high as 200 (unless they hustled him earlier), to agree to talk to Trudy or join them in the attack, the latter of which turns Trudy and Patrick hostile.

Talking to Trudy after Wolfgang results in her refusing to pay up. The conversation can take one of a few turns:

  1. The player character can offer to help her instead, in which case she will offer 100 caps to kill Wolfgang. This can be haggled up to 125, 150 or as high as 200. Refusal to help Trudy turns her hostile.
  2. She can also be convinced or threatened to pay up. If the "end peacefully" option fails, the quest defaults to her offer to kill Wolfgang. If the "Threaten" option fails, she will turn hostile. If either option succeeds, the standoff comes to an end.

By this point, talk to whoever is still alive to complete the quest:

Quest stages

Quest stages
StageStatusDescriptionLog Entry
20 Talk with Wolfgang or Trudy
70 Talk with Trudy - Spoke to Wolfgang firstWolfgang over at the Drumlin Diner says Trudy owes him money she won't pay. He's offering me a reward if I resolve their disagreement.
75 Kill Wolfgang - Spoke with Trudy firstTrudy, the owner of the Drumlin Diner, is offering me a reward if I kill Wolfgang, a local chem dealer who got her son addicted to Jet.
1000 Talk with Wolfgang - Trudy and Patrick deadTrudy and her son are dead. Wolfgang will be happy about this.
2000 Talk with Trudy - Wolfgang and Simone deadWolfgang and his friend are dead. Trudy should be happy about this.
2100 Talk with Trudy - Wolfgang and Simone ran awayI managed to frighten Wolfgang and his friend off. Trudy, the owner of the Drumlin Diner, will be happy now that they're gone.
3000 Talk with Wolfgang - Convinced Trudy to pay debtI convinced Trudy to pay off Wolfgang. He'll be pleased to hear about this.
4000 Talk to TrudyI put an end to the conflict between Trudy and Wolfgang at the Drumlin Diner.
5000 Talk to WolfgangI put an end to the conflict between Trudy and Wolfgang at the Drumlin Diner.
6000Quest failedQuest failed - everyone deadEveryone in the Drumlin Diner is dead. Whatever mess these people had gotten themselves into doesn't matter now.
6100Quest failedQuest failed - everyone hostileI've attacked everyone at the Drumlin Diner. Whatever problems they had hardly matter now.
7000Quest finishedQuest complete

Companion reactions

EventCaitCodsworthCurieDanseDeaconHancockMacCreadyPiperPrestonStrongValentineX6-88LongfellowGage
Intimidate Wolfgang into lowering his gun.LoveDislikesDislikesLikeDislikesLikeLikeDislikesLikeLikeDislikesLikeNo reactionNo reaction
Offer to help when talking to Wolfgang.No reactionLikeLikeNo reactionLikeNo reactionNo reactionLikeDislikesNo reactionLikeDislikesNo reactionNo reaction
Being sarcastic with Wolfgang.LikeDislikesDislikesDislikesNo reactionNo reactionLikeNo reactionDislikesNo reactionNo reactionNo reactionNo reactionNo reaction
Asking for payment from Wolfgang after his money was demanded earlier.No reactionDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesNo reactionNo reactionDislikesDislikesDislikesNo reactionLikeNo reactionNo reaction
Remarking that Trudy and Patrick should pay when talking to Wolfgang.DislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesNo reactionNo reactionNo reaction
Saying that both Trudy and Wolfgang are in the wrong.LikeNo reactionNo reactionNo reactionNo reactionNo reactionNo reactionLikeLikeNo reactionLikeNo reactionNo reactionNo reaction
Calling Wolfgang a scumbag.LikeLikeDislikesLikeLikeNo reactionLikeLikeLikeLikeLikeNo reactionNo reactionNo reaction
Joining the attack against Trudy.DislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesLikeDislikesLikeNo reactionNo reaction
Offering to negotiate with Trudy when talking to Wolfgang.DislikesLikeLikeDislikesLikeNo reactionDislikesLikeLikeDislikesLikeNo reactionNo reactionNo reaction
Threatening Trudy into paying up.HatesDislikesDislikesHatesDislikesHatesDislikesHatesDislikesLikeHatesLikeNo reactionNo reaction
Convincing Trudy to peacefully work it out with Wolfgang.DislikesLikeLikeLikeDislikesDislikesDislikesLikeLikeDislikesLikeNo reactionNo reactionNo reaction
Offering to help Trudy before she reveals the attack on Wolfgang.No reactionLikeLikeDislikesLikeNo reactionNo reactionLikeLikeNo reactionLikeDislikesNo reactionNo reaction
Haggling with Trudy over the cost of Wolfgang's life.LikeHatesDislikesHatesDislikesNo reactionNo reactionDislikesDislikesDislikesDislikesLikeNo reactionNo reaction
Joining the attack against Wolfgang.LikeDislikesDislikesDislikesLikeLikeLikeDislikesDislikesLikeDislikesLikeNo reactionNo reaction
Refusing to join the attack against Wolfgang.DislikesLikeLikeNo reactionDislikesDislikesDislikesLikeLikeDislikesLikeNo reactionNo reactionNo reaction

Notes

Bugs

PCPC Playstation 4Playstation 4 Xbox OneXbox One If Wolfgang is killed during the "Talk to Wolfgang" objective at quest stage 3000, the objective will not clear, making the quest impossible to complete. The quest can still be failed by killing Trudy and Patrick.[verified]